Elon Musk pedo guy defamation trial: Tesla CEO takes witness stand – Business Insider

  • Elon Musk took the witness stand on the first day of his defamation trial Tuesday.
  • The Tesla CEO is being sued by Vernon Unsworth, a British diver who took part in the 2018 rescue operation that freed 12 boys and a soccer coach who were trapped inside a cave in Thailand.
  • Musk and Unsworth clashed at the height of that mission, after which the Tesla executive called Unsworth “pedo guy” on Twitter. Lawyers for Unsworth say that remark was widely interpreted as Musk suggesting the diver was a pedophile. 
  • On Tuesday, Musk told the court he had been set off by an interview Unsworth gave to CNN after the rescue where he criticized Musk for trying to get involved. Musk called Unsworth’s remarks “wrong and insulting.” He testified that his “pedo guy” tweet about Unsworth “didn’t literally mean he was a pedophile.” 
  • Sign up for Business Insider’s transportation newsletter, Shifting Gears, to get more stories like this in your inbox.
  • Visit Business Insider’s homepage for more stories.

LOS ANGELES — Tesla CEO Elon Musk made his first courtroom appearance on Tuesday as a defendant in a defamation case stemming from a 2018 tweet in which he called a man “pedo guy.”

The target of Musk’s insult was Vernon Unsworth, a British diver who took part in the 2018 rescue operation that freed 12 boys who were members of a soccer team and their coach after they became trapped inside a cave in Thailand.

Musk and Unsworth had clashed at the height of that mission. Afterward, the Tesla executive lobbed the “pedo guy” insult at the diver on Twitter.

Lawyers for Unsworth argued that the remark was widely interpreted as Musk suggesting the diver was a pedophile. Musk has denied that assertion, saying the phrase is a common expression in South Africa where he was born. Musk’s lawyers unsuccessfully sought to have the case thrown out before trial.

The proceedings began with jury selection on Tuesday. Several potential jurors were dismissed for various reasons, many of whom disclosed professional connections with Musk and his various companies, including SpaceX, the Boring Company, and Neuralink. The Guardian reported that one person was sent home after saying he had an upcoming job interview with SpaceX, and a woman was sent away when she admitted she held “strong opinions about billionaires.”

After opening statements, Musk took the witness stand and offered some insight into what led to his 2018 tie-up with Unsworth.

vernon unsworth and lin wood

L. Lin Wood, right, attorney for plaintiff, British cave expert Vernon Unsworth, left, arrives for the trial against Tesla CEO Elon Musk at U.S. District Court Tuesday, Dec. 3, 2019, in Los Angeles.
AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill


The Tesla CEO told the court he was incensed by an interview Unsworth gave to CNN after the rescue where a mini submarine that Musk sent to the divers went unused. Unsworth called Musk’s attempts to get involved in the mission a “PR stunt” while the rescuers were busy developing a plan to remove the boys and their coach from the Tham Luong cave in northern Thailand.

Unsworth told CNN that Musk “can stick his submarine where it hurts.” In court, Musk said Unsworth’s remarks hurt him.

“So I insulted him back,” Musk testified, adding: “I didn’t literally mean he was a pedophile.” 

Lawyers challenged Musk on that assertion, pointing to a follow-up tweet in which Musk said, “Bet ya a signed dollar it’s true,” in reference to his original “pedo guy” tweet. The tweets were deleted hours after he posted them in 2018.

Musk snapped back on the witness stand, saying he would have wagered more money if he thought it was true.

During one heated exchange, Musk accused Unsworth’s attorney, L. Lin Wood, of trying to shake him down in his initial letter to Musk, calling it “extortion, essentially.” 

“I get these shakedown letters quite a lot,” he said.

The Tesla exec also faced tough questions about his intent and frame of mind around the ordeal. At one point, Unsworth’s lawyers sought to determine whether Musk understood the potential legal consequences of publicly calling Unsworth “pedo guy,” BuzzFeed News’ Ryan Mac reported, citing an August 2018 tweet Musk sent in which he wondered out loud why the diver hadn’t sued him yet.

Unsworth’s lawyers must successfully prove that Musk’s actions demonstrated negligence to the extent that they harmed Unsworth. The diver already notched a victory in earlier proceedings where the judge ruled he is not a public figure, which lowers the threshold for proving defamation.

Musk is expected back on the witness stand Wednesday.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.